Pros and Cons of MP3 CDs

MP3 CDs hold many files at compressed quality

Man inserting MP3 CD
Tetra Images/Getty Images

The generic term "MP3 CD" refers to the storage of digital audio files—usually MP3s—on compact discs (CDs). These files are stored like any other file on a regular CD-ROM using the Yellow Book CD standard. This storage method differs from audio CDs—the type you buy in music stores—where the recorded audio files are encoded on optical media in an uncompressed format using the Red Book CD standard. The quality of audio CDs is much higher than the quality of compressed MP3s.

Although MP3 CD suggests that only MP3 files can be stored to conform to this type of CD, that isn't the case. You can create compilations of audio files, songs, audiobooks, and podcasts that are mixes of different audio formats. However, when you deviate from the MP3 format, there is no guarantee that CD and DVD consumer electronic devices such as some CD players can play all the audio formats stored on your custom CD. You can minimize this problem by using only MP3 and other well-supported formats such as WAV and ACC when you make the MP3 CD.

Advantages of Using an MP3 CD

Because the audio of a normal audio CD is not compressed, it only contains a single music album or a collection of songs with a maximum playing time of approximately 80 minutes. By creating an MP3 CD, you significantly extend this maximum playing time and can store many more songs than on a standard audio CD. Music stored in a digital audio file format like MP3 is encoded in a compressed format and takes up a lot less storage space on a CD. With an MP3 CD, you can record eight to 10 albums on one disc. The exact number is dependent on the format, encoding method, and the bit rate used.

Disadvantages of Using an MP3 CD for Audio Files

MP3 CDs may offer the advantage of being able to store more music than a regular audio CD, but there are disadvantages. They are:

  • Inferior Audio Reproduction. The sound quality of the audio from an MP3 CD is inferior to the sound from a typical music CD. The stored audio data format in the MP3 CD is a lossy one, whereas audio CDs contain uncompressed—and therefore lossless—audio.
  • Reduced Compatibility. MP3 CDs are less compatible with consumer electronic devices than purchased audio CDs are. Although many modern hardware devices such DVD and CD players support the MP3 format along with WMA, AAC, and others, some hardware equipment only supports the playback of uncompressed audio CDs.