Guide to Digital Camcorder Memory Formats

Young girl holding camcorder on beach

JGI / Jamie Grill / Getty Images

Digital camcorders record video to a variety of memory formats: Digital 8, Mini DV, DVD discs, hard disk drives (HDD), flash memory cards and Blu-ray Discs. Each camcorder memory format has its strength and weakness. It’s important to familiarize yourself with the various camcorder memory formats because the type of memory a camcorder records to will have a major impact on its size, battery life, and ease-of-use.

Digital Tape

Digital tape has ultimately fallen off with the rise of SD cards, but there are two primary digital tape formats: Digital 8 and Mini DV. Digital 8 is an 8mm style tape used only by Sony. Mini DV records video to small cassettes. While you’ll find both formats on the market, camcorder manufacturers are steadily reducing the number of tape-based camcorders they sell.

While tape-based camcorders are less expensive than their rivals, they’re not as convenient, at least where transferring video to a computer is concerned. Moving digital video from a tape-based camcorder to a computer is done in real time – an hour of footage takes an hour to transfer. Other formats such as HDD or flash memory, transfer video significantly faster.

If you’re less concerned with storing and editing video on a computer, tape formats still provide a high quality, low-cost digital option.

DVD Camcorders

DVD camcorders record digital video onto a small DVD. DVD camcorders typically record video in the MPEG-2 format and can be played back in a DVD player immediately after recording. DVD camcorders are good for consumers who want to be able to instantly watch their video after recording and are not interested in editing the video. Blank DVDs are also fairly inexpensive and easy to find.

DVD camcorders do have limitations. Because the disc is constantly spinning, the camcorder battery will drain quicker. If you jostle the disc while it’s in motion, you could disrupt your recording. If you opt for a high definition DVD camcorder, you’ll have a very limited recording time, particularly at higher quality levels. DVD camcorders are also fairly bulky.

Hard Disk Drive (HDD) Camcorders

Hard disk drive camcorders record video directly onto an internal hard drive on your camcorder. HDD camcorders have the highest capacity of any storage format available – meaning you can fit hours upon hours of video on the drive without having to transfer it to a computer. Items on a hard disk drive camcorder can be deleted and moved around within the camcorder allowing camcorder users the ability to easily organize their video.

While hard drive camcorders can store hours of footage, they also have moving parts. This means the battery will drain quicker and jostling of the device can potentially disrupt recording.

Flash Memory Cards

The same flash memory cards used in digital cameras are used to store digital video. The two most popular format is on SD/SDHC cards, used by the majority of camcorder manufacturers.

Flash memory cards have several advantages over other camcorder formats. They’re small, so flash memory camcorders can be significantly smaller and lighter than their competitors. Flash memory has no moving parts, so there’s less drain on the battery and no concern about disrupted video due to excessive jostling.

It’s not all upside, however. Flash memory cards can’t store as much video as an HDD. If you’re going on an extended vacation, you’ll have to pack an extra card or two. And high capacity memory cards aren’t cheap.

Blu-Ray Disc

To date, only one manufacturer (Hitachi) offers camcorders that record directly to high definition Blu-ray disc. The advantage here is similar to DVD – you can do your filming and then drop the disc directly into a Blu-ray disc player for HD playback.

Blu-ray discs can store more video than a DVD, however, they’re susceptible to the other drawbacks of DVD: moving parts and a bulkier design.