Color Perception and Your TV

Standardized Video Color Chart and The Famous Dress
Standardized Video Color Chart and The Famous Dress. Color Chart provided by Silicon Optix/IDT/Qualcomm - Dress Images Public Domain

Back in 2015, a simple inquiry regarding what color specific dress was sparked widespread interest on how we perceive color. The fact is, there are certain things you need to know about perceiving color in the real world.

What We Really See

Our eyes don't see the actual object(s), what you actually see is the result of light that is reflected off of the object. The color you see is the result of what light wavelengths are reflected or absorbed by the object.

Read the article How The Eye Sees Color from Colormatters.com for further reference

However, depending on additional factors, it is unlikely that the color you see is totally correct. Wired and UCSB Science Line both have a pretty good summation of issues involving real world color perception, while PBS offers up an additional perspective.

Factors Affecting Color Perception

The perception of color in the real world is affected by several elements:

Physical Properties of an Object: What wavelengths of light does an object reflect or absorb naturally due to its physical makeup?

Time of Day: Is the object being seen in morning light, afternoon, or night light?

Location: Is the object being seen in outdoor light (sunny or cloudy day) or artificial indoor light (and what type of indoor light)?

Color Perception: Natural variations in how each pair of human eyes perceives color wavelengths.

Color Blindness: Unnatural variations in how some humans are able to perceive color wavelengths.

Color in the Home Theater Environment

In addition to real world color perception scenarios, in photo, printing, and video there are also additional factors to take into consideration:

Instrument Used In Capturing the Image: The capabilities of a camera to detect color wavelengths in combination with time of day and location.

Display Device Used In Reproducing The Image: TV, Video Projector, Print

Display or Printer Calibration: If viewing the image in print or a video display device, what standard was used to calibrate that device for color reproduction, if any?

Capturing Color

Although there are both commonalities and differences between color perception with regards to photo, print, and video applications, let's zero in on the video side of the equation.

The image you see on your TV or video projection screen is the end of a highly technical process.

First, you have to "capture" the image.

In order to do this, a video camera has to sense the light reflecting off objects and coming through a lens. The entering light consists of all the colors that are reflected off the target object(s). That light enters the lens and hits a chip (in the old days, before chips, the light had to pass through a specially built vacuum tube).

Once the light lands on the chip, there is a process employed by the chip, and supporting circuitry, that converts the light into either analog electrical pulse, or digital codes (1's, 0's). This converted signal is then sent to a receiving device (in this case a TV or video projector) that will convert incoming electrical pulse (analog) or digital code back into an image that is displayed or projected onto a screen.

However, here is where it gets tricky, as the capturing device has the task of receiving the light reflected off an object at a given point in time and the display device has to present the color of the captured result accurately.

Since neither the capturing device nor the display device can reproduce all of the color that is reflected from the real world, both devices have to "guess" based on specific "man made" color standards, which have at its foundation, a three primary color model. In video applications, the three color model is represented by Red, Green, and Blue. Different combinations of the three primary colors in various ratios is intended to recreate all color shades, including black and white that we see in nature.

Displaying Color via a TV or Video Projector

So, if there is no definitive correctness on how humans perceive color in the natural world, and there are limitations capturing accurate color using a camera, how is this reconciled in the home environment when watching TV or a video projector?

The answer is two-fold, the physical capabilities of the display device, and the use of scientifically determined color standards to fine tune the capability of the TV or video projector to display as close to accurate color as possible within a determined color standard.

First, here is a brief overview of the types of video display technologies used in home theater realm for displaying both B&W and color images.

Emissive Technologies

CRT - An electron beam originating in the next of a picture tube scans rows of phosphors on a line-by-line basis in order to produce an image. As the beam hits each phosphor, the phosphor is excited and produces the image. Color is produced by red, green, and blue phosphors excited in the proper combination to produce a specific color.

Plasma - Phosphors are lit by superheated charged gas (similar to a Fluorescent light). Combinations of red, green, and blue phosphors (referred to as pixels and sub-pixels) produce the designated color.

OLED - OLED technology can be implemented in several ways for TVs. LG employs a process, referred as WRGB, which combines white OLED self-emitting subpixels with Red, Green, and Blue color filters, whereas Samsung employs Red, Green, and Blue sub-pixels with no added color filters.

Transmissive Technologies

LCD - LCD pixels do not produce their own light. In order for an LCD TV to display an image on TV screen the LCD's pixels have to be "backlit". The backlight, in most cases, is constant. What happens in this process is that the pixels are rapidly turned on and off depending on the requirements of the image. If the pixels are off, they don't let the backlight through, when they are on, they let the backlight through.

The base image is produced by the lit LCD Chips, and color is added as the light travels through the LCD chip and then through the red, green, and blue color filters. NOTE: Sharp employs a variation of this system, referred to as Quattron, that adds a fourth LCD subpixel paired with a yellow color filter in addition to the red, green, and blue color filter/sub-pixel pairs.

3LCD - Used in video projection, works in a similar manner to LCD TV, but instead, chips scattered through an entire screen source, white light is passed through three LCD chips and a Prism and then projected onto a screen.

Transmissive/Emissive Combinations

LCD with Quantum Dots

For the purposes of application in TVs and video displays, a Quantum Dot is a manmade man-made nanocrystal with special light-emitting properties that can be used to enhance the brightness and color performance displayed in still and video images on an LCD screen.

Quantum Dots are nanoparticles with adjustable emissive properties that can absorb higher energy light of one color and emit lower light of another color (somewhat like phosphors on a Plasma TV), but, in this case, when they are hit with photons from an outside light source (in the case of LCD TV application a Blue LED light), each quantum dot emits color of a specific wavelength, which is determined by its size.

Quantum Dots can be incorporated into an LCD TV is three ways:

1. Placed inside of thin glass tube (referred to as an Edge Optic) inside the TV's light source structure between a blue LED edge light source and the Light Guide Plate (the structure that spreads the light across the screen area) for edge-lit LED/LCD TVs.

2. On a "film enhancement layer" placed between a Blue LED light source and the the LCD chip and color filters (for Full Array or Direct-Lit LED/LCD TVs).

3. On a chip, where quantum dots are integrated directly on a blue LED dies for use in either edge or direct-lit configurations.

For each option (determined by the TV maker), the Blue LED light hits the Quantum Dots, which are then excited so that they emit red and green light (which is also combined with the Blue coming from the LED light source). The colored light then passes through the LCD chips, color filters, and on to the screen for image display. The added Quantum Dot emissive layer allows the LCD TV to display a more saturated and wider color gamut than LCD TVs without the added Quantum Dot layer.

Reflective Technologies

LCOS (also referred to as D-ILA and SXRD)

LCOS is a variant of 3LCD and is used in video projection, but instead of passing light through each of the three LCD chips and then through color filters and the lens, the LCD chip is on top of a reflective base, so when a colored light source passes through the chip is automatically reflected back and is sent through the lens to the projection screen.

For more technical details on LCOS technology, check out How LCOS Works.

DLP (3-Chip) - Used in Video Projectors - The key to DLP is the DMD (Digital Micro-mirror Device), in which every chip is made up of tiny tiltable mirrors. This means that every pixel on a DMD chip is a reflective mirror.

The video image is displayed on the DMD chip. The micromirrors on the chip (remember: each micromirror represents one pixel) then tilt very rapidly as the image changes. This process produces the grayscale foundation for the image.

In a 3-Chip DLP video projector, three light sources are used (or white light passed through three prisms). The colored light is then reflective off of three DLP chips (they are all grayscale, but are each is receiving different colored light). The degree of tilt of each micromirror in relation to the color light source at any given time determines the colors in the image. The reflected light is then passed through the projector's lens to the screen.

Reflective/Transmissive Combination

DLP (1-Chip) - Used in Video Projectors - In this arrangement, there is a single white light source that is reflected off of a single DLP DMD chip. Then, color is added as reflected light passes through a high-speed color wheel, through the lens, and then to the screen.

For further technical explanations on DLP, check out my article: DLP as well as the Texas Instruments DLP Website.

Displaying Color - Calibration Standards

So, now that the electronics and mechanics have been worked out on how a color image gets to either your TV or video projection screen, the next step is to figure out how make sure that the color using those devices is as close to what you would see in the real world as possible, despite technology limitations.

This is where the application of color standards within the visible Color Space become important.

Some of the color calibration standards for TVs and Video Projectors that are in use currently are:

NTSC (The basic standard for analog color)

Rec.601 (Improvement over basic NTSC standard).

Rec.709 (For use with HDTVs and HD Video Projectors)

Rec.2020 (Developing standard intended for with 4K Ultra HD TVs and Video Projectors)

sRGB (For Use Mostly in PC Monitors for displaying graphics)

Using a combination of hardware (colorimeter) and software (usually via a laptop), a person can fine tune a TV or video projectors color reproduction capability to one of above standards (depending on the TV's color specifications) via adjustments provided in either the video/display settings, or service menu of the TV or video projector.

Examples of basic video (color) calibration tools that you can use, without the need of a technician, include test discs, such as Digital Video Essentials, Disney WOW (World of Wonder) DVD and Blu-ray Test Discs, the Spears and Munsil HD Benchmark, the THX Calibrator Disc, and the THX Tune Home Theater Tune-up App for compatible iOS and Android phones/tablets. An example of a basic video calibration tool that employs a Colorimeter and PC software, is the Datacolor Spyder4TV Color Calibration System.

If you are looking for a more extensive calibration tool, check out Calman products by SpectraCal.

The reason the above tools are desirable, and even necessary, is that just as indoor and outdoor lighting conditions affect the ability of us to see color in the real word, those same factors also come to play as to what the color will look like on your TV or video projection screen under similar conditions, also taking into consideration how flexible your TV or projector is at providing the necessary adjustment features to accomplish this fact.

Calibration adjustments not only include things that apply to both photography and video, such as brightness, contrast, color saturation, and tint control, but also other necessary adjustments, such as White Balance, Color Temperature, and Gamma.

Closing Thoughts

So, as you can see, color perception for both the real world and TV viewing environments involves complicated processes, as well as other external factors. Color perception is more of a guessing game than a precise science. The human eye is the best tool we have so far, and although, in photography, film, and video, accurate color can be tagged to a specific color standard, the color you see on a printed photograph, TV, or video projection screen, even if they meet 100% of a specific color standards specification, still can't look exactly the same as how it might look under real world conditions.

More On Color Perception: Seven Color Optical Illusions (Women's Health Magazine)

Original Publish Date: 03/02/2015 - Robert Silva